A Superintendent’s Grim Stance
When Did We Say It Was OK?
A superintendent's grim stance on the normalization of extreme student behaviors.
Jane Stavem
Superintendent of the Sioux Falls School District
November 01, 2024
In education, we find ourselves at a crossroads, asking ourselves: When did we say it was OK? “It” refers to the normalization of extreme student behaviors in our schools, threatening our profession’s foundation.
Superintendents, administrators and teachers are witnessing escalating violence and destruction in classrooms. Physical assaults on staff — being kicked, punched, sworn at or threatened — have become disturbingly common.
Schools have become the default placement for kids with complex needs, not because they are equipped but because they are public institutions designed to welcome all.
Beyond Reason
The question isn’t about blame but reflection. When did we decide we were qualified to address severe student needs in a school setting? Schools exist to impart knowledge and foster learning, but educators are forced into roles akin to security personnel.
Our primary goal — educating the next generation — is being overshadowed by unreasonable demands. When did it become acceptable for schools to bear the blunt force of societal challenges without adequate support? When did navigating extreme behaviors become normalized? The encroachment of severe mental
health issues into classrooms has left us scrambling to address problems beyond our capacity, leading to an unsustainable situation.
This is not to dismiss the importance of mental health support, but public schools are not the right setting for handling severe cases. Protecting all students is vital, and we must recalibrate the balance between the needs of individuals and the safety and well-being of the entire school community.
When did we agree to add more meetings, make ill-equipped accommodations or modify instructional spaces? Increasingly, the fear of lawsuits has pushed us to stretch beyond reasonable boundaries, diverting us from our core mission of teaching and learning. Schools are not psychiatric units, hospitals or prisons.
We need to work with communities and lawmakers to shift the focus and direct resources to organizations and specialists that can better address these complex needs.
Alternative Support
Consider other professions: Would a surgeon tolerate a patient disrupting surgery or throwing surgical tools on the floor? Would a pastor allow a screaming parishioner to stay for the whole sermon? Would a retail store allow a customer to return after repeatedly destroying displays? No, they wouldn’t. Yet these kinds of behaviors persist in our schools, undermining the very purpose of education.
When I began teaching, I learned a fundamental question that was designed to determine whether it was appropriate for a student to stay in the classroom: Can teachers keep teaching and students keep learning? Under circumstances of extreme behavior, the answer is increasingly no. Our responsibility is to teach so students can learn. We cannot allow anything to erode that core purpose to the point where public education ceases to exist.
Are schools the only places left to help children? It’s time to reassess our role and advocate for systems and services that provide support where it is genuinely needed, ensuring public education remains focused on its core mission.
- Dr. Jane Stavem
KELOLAND News spoke with Stavem on Monday about what prompted her to write her article. It was published a few days after she announced she would be stepping down as SFSD Superintendent.
“When I first wrote it, I had been in a couple of our own schools and we just continue to see behaviors that really are outpacing all of the interventions, resources, staffing, all of the things that many districts have put in place,” Stavem told KELOLAND News. One of Stavem’s solutions is increasing funding and partnerships with mental health providers and placing students in specialized programs when appropriate. In Sioux Falls, it can take a family months to get an appointment with a mental health professional, and even longer in rural areas.
“That’s where we need our community members, our elected officials, our governor and elected body in the legislature to really step up and say we’ve got to figure out some plan here because school districts cannot continue to bear the burden of this alone,” Stavem said. “We have to have more options and better treatment available.”
In terms of funding, Stavem said it isn’t an “either/or” situation. She said school districts need to be adequately funded to continue educating students, but money and resources need to also go toward getting help for students who are struggling. “We are not psychologists, we are not in patient residential settings, we are not equipped for some of the substance abuse issues that our students face,” Stavem said on Monday. “We do teaching and learning, so that funding also has to be allocated for those other supporting roles.
Here a take from Change Agent Beverly Froslie Johnson, a recent legislative candidate for District 9:
Here a take from Change Agent Beverly Froslie Johnson, a recent legislative candidate for District 9:
I think there are two sides to this issue. Being a parent of a child with autism and other mental health diagnoses plus an advocate for other parents, I attend numerous IEP meetings. Teachers are being kicked, hit and peed on but most school districts are denying services and supports which parents are fighting for. Schools are saying "we have a program" to keep the child in the district while Avera Behavioral Health is a revolving door for them. South Dakota doesn't have the facilities and schools don't have the necessary funding to help these students. South Dakota spends $10 million dollars a year for out of state youth placements. I was able to change one law to better support youth in accessing the necessary help they need, but there's a lot more that needs to be done!