In South Dakota, 135 Years of History Is That The People Rule. Amendment L Would End That

Welcome to South Dakota

by Henry Travers

South Dakota has been riven with party politics throughout its history. Even South Dakota’s own statehood was sidetracked by United States Senate Democrats in the late 1800s. Once statehood was achieved, though, Republicans have dominated the state’s governments. While Republican values and foundations have changed, particularly in recent times, the goal of continuing dominion remains overarching. Party over the people is today a legacy mantra evident both in South Dakota and in Congress. The will of the People – a majority of the People – can be subverted by a dominating legislature in our state as it has in other states (e.g. Missouri) when it comes to laws, but constitutional amendments do not permit such easy manipulation of the popular will.

south dakota

History. South Dakota territory, when it first included only what are today North and South Dakota, was politically mixed, the southern portion becoming firmly Republican. Efforts by the territory’s southern half to achieve statehood, begun in 1879 and gaining momentum after the territorial capital was moved from Yankton to Bismarck in 1883, were stymied by the United States Congress. Statehood required the assent of Congress and it was then controlled by Democrats who were reluctant (party over people) to admit a state that would “send two more Republicans to the United States Senate.”[1]

north dakota

It would not be until the election of 1888, when Republican Benjamin Harrison became president and members of his party controlled both houses of Congress that an Enabling Act was passed to create the state of South Dakota.

By that time two constitutional conventions had been held (in 1883 and 1885), the latter producing a Constitution that, with a few minor modifications and adjusted to conform to federal requirements, became the initial governing document of the state, ratified by a popular vote of 70,131 for to 3,267 against.[1] Over the next 135 years it was modified multiple times – it was, in fact, modified 52 times in the first 28 years of statehood[2] - by a majority vote of the citizens (called “electors” in the document) of the state. Underpinning the requirement of citizen participation were provisions in Article III and Article VI (Bill of Rights). The latter stated: “All political power is inherent in the People…and they have the right in lawful and constituted methods to alter or reform their forms of government in such a manner as they think proper.” This provision persists in the most recent (2023) version of the Constitution.[3] Article III(§1) provides “…that the people expressly reserve to themselves the right to propose measures, which measures the legislature shall enact and submit to a vote of the electors of the state, and also the right to require that any laws which the legislature may have enacted shall be submitted to a vote of the electors of the state before going into effect…Provided, that not more than five per centum of the qualified electors of the state shall be required to invoke either the initiative or the referendum.”  This, too, persists in the current Constitution. An amendment to extend initiative and referendum to municipalities was defeated by voters in 1914.

history of SD

Amendment of the Constitution. The original Constitution (Article XXIII) permitted amendment either by initiative or by a “majority vote of all members of each house of the Legislature.” An initiative is a process that empowers citizens to propose and enact laws or constitutional amendments directly through a vote. The basic elements of this Article are unchanged today, including the requirement of a majority vote. The original constitutional language allowed an amendment to change more than one article, but that is no longer in the current Constitution.

Proposed Changes to the Majority Requirement. In 2018 and 2022 the legislature proposed amending the Constitution to require supermajorities of 55% (Amendment X applying to all constitutional changes in 2018) or 60% (Amendment C applying just to amendments regarding taxes and fees in 2022) for constitutional amendment. Both of these were rejected by voters, Amendment C by 67%.  In 2024 the legislature proposed yet another amendment (Amendment L) to require a 60% majority.

At the time of its legislative passage, sponsors of Amendment L aimed to address three driving concerns: (1) out-of-state influences, (2) the foundational nature of the Constitution, and (3) reserving the Constitution for structural rather than policy matters.

Out-of-State Influences. For many entities (corporations, organizations interested in human rights, healthcare organizations and foundations like the Heritage Foundation) which promote structural and social viewpoints, state boundaries have become transparent to their interests. There have been and will continue to be national or regional interests advocating one position or another that may contribute their out-of-state money and resources to in-state proponents or opponents of issues. In the world of realpolitik, one “side” or party may be far better funded in general, a factor that can be more influential in determining outcomes than the strengths of argument on either side. Requiring a super-majority for constitutional amendment would thus seem to favor more deep-pocketed interests. To be sure, well-funded efforts to influence the voting public perform better than those poorly-funded, but funding is only as effective as the messages it supports.

There is no evidence that requiring a supermajority for constitutional amendment will relieve the state of external influences in matters of policy. It will, though, unbalance the scale of popular choice with the weight of gold by increasing the amount of money required to exert influence. To the extent that such financial resources exceed those available within South Dakota, it becomes  more difficult for a majority of South Dakota citizens themselves to exercise their constitutionally mandated power.

The legislature had already disposed of an issue related to out-of-state interests coming from the estimated 30,000 individuals registered to vote in the state who are not year-around residents. Because they are registered, they could sign petitions for an initiated measure and perhaps even contribute money to supporters. Beginning this July 1, 2025, the 30-day residency requirement for voter registration included maintaining a fixed permanent dwelling in which they physically resided for 30 days. This should effectively eliminate from voter rolls most of those individuals whose addresses are listed in locations where no one lives or are businesses.

The Constitution as a Foundational Document. That the South Dakota Constitution sets forth the basic structure of state government is an argument for characterizing it as foundational. Changes to the structure of the executive, legislative and judicial branches – how they are organized, membership, authorities and powers – alter the foundation of how the People wish to be governed.

The Constitution, though, covers much more than that. From its beginning, it has contained many other provisions unrelated to foundational purposes. These policy issues are related to, for example, the drainage of agricultural lands, regulation of banking corporations, school lands, the sale of school supplies, road building, and railroad corporations. Through the last 125 years, these and other detailed items were changed and others added to meet the requirements of a shifting culture and economy as well as transformations of public sentiment and viewpoints.

SD seal

Thus, only parts of the Constitution are truly foundational; much of it is, in fact, operational policy. Of those truly foundational parts, the ultimate authority of a majority of citizens to exercise governing power is the most important. Altering that authority therefore alters the most foundational part of the entire document.

Separating Policy from the Constitution. The Constitution has never separated “structure” from “policy.” The current Constitution continues the 135-year-old tradition of including matters of policy including banking, highway fees, attorney regulations, banking, education, mining, corporations, divorce, land drainage, elevator operation, flour mills, gambling and so on. It simply makes no sense to propose that requiring a supermajority to change the Constitution will eliminate any of these and achieve the suggested result (separation of structure and policy).

under god the people rule

“Under God, the People Rule” should never become a hollow motto. Our legislature, through Amendment L, proposes to replace it, continuing to invoke the Almighty in its quest to rule the state alone or through a minority of voters. Whether or not they succeed remains up to the People. Do We the People keep our power - a power that has, for more than a century, served us well - or do we relinquish it either to a small group of men and women in the legislature or to a 40% minority who would replace the People’s Will with their own?

Stand fast, fellow citizens; our future in is our hands… if we can keep it.

[1] Garry and Spurlin History, 32.

[2] Constitution of the State of South Dakota 1917. Gates JH (Annotator). Pierre: South Dakota Secretary of State, 1917.

[3] It is of interest, in our current political climate, that the original document (Article VII) permitted those foreign born who “…shall have declared their intention to become citizens conformably to the laws of the United States…” to vote.  Article VII no longer contains this language.

Leave a Comment